Auto Insurance

Low to Mid-Income Americans Paying Too Much for Auto Insurance

According to figures compiled by the Consumer Federation of America, low to mid-level income Americans may be paying too much for their auto insurance policies, a situation which lowers their employment opportunities because they cannot legally drive an uninsured vehicle. On average, this class of driver pays $700 and up for their auto coverage.

Insurers rely on a variety of factors to determine premium levels including the location of the primary residence, the driver’s occupation, and their level of education. Insurers insist that when taken as a whole, these facts contribute to the degree of risk associated with the driver’s operation of a motor vehicle.

Stephen Brobeck, CFA president, said in a statement accompanying the release of the study, “As a society, we must figure out a way for lower-income families to purchase affordable liability coverage so that they don’t face the choice between breaking the law and giving up access to job opportunities.”

Unfortunately, this is too often a case of presumed “guilt” on the part of the car owner rather than innocence. One option for low-income drivers is to investigate the newly emerging class of “pay as you drive” coverage.

This insurance model includes the installation of a device on the car to collect data about miles driven, the time of day the car is in operation, and rate of speed. It may also look at behavior like abrupt stops and accelerations.

The policy’s premium levels are tied to actual driver behavior, which the motorist can monitor on the company’s website. Studies have shown that already safe drivers become even safer when they can see data about their own habits behind the wheel.

The “pay as you drive” model offers one solution to what would appear to be a “class-based” insurance dilemma. Every state in the union except New Hampshire and Wisconsin require motorists to carry insurance. Given the effects of the on-going recession, more drivers are having to weigh the dangers of breaking the law and driving uninsured because they cannot afford their auto insurance premiums.

The CFA study, “Lower-Income Households and the Auto Insurance Marketplace: Challenges and Opportunities” can be accessed at

Like this post? Please share it!
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Tumblr
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter

By Rana

Rana K. Williamson, 48, a former university professor who is now a professional writer and researcher, focuses on cost-saving techniques and insurance news. Located in Texas, she has a particular interest in auto and motorcycle insurance because, as she explains, "When you live in a state this large, you're always behind the wheel of your car. And, well, bikes are just cool. Period." Readers contact Dr. Williamson with those questions that take a little extra digging and that relate to the latest changes in the world of insurance. "One of the most important things in managing costs in any field is to understand the basics and to stay abreast of the latest developments," said Williamson. "I enjoy using my love of research to answer questions and to track down information." Contact Dr. Williamson at with your own insurance-related and cost-managing questions.

Leave a Reply